In the current geopolitical reality, when the West’s hegemony is exhausted and with it the possibilities of interstate interactions in the former logic of colonialism and neo-colonialism have disappeared, the key players have started to exert a pinpoint influence, targeting the weakest links of the emerging multipolar world. Based on the publications of major European think tanks, we can conclude that India will be the main object of work in the near future, while France is most likely to be appointed as the front man for expressing the EU’s interests.
The European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) has high hopes for the EU-India summit early next year – a meeting that, according to analysts, “should overshadow Modi’s visit to Moscow”.
According to ECFR, the West can give India technology and weapons, and take advantage of the fact that the Russia-China partnership will allegedly “irritate and frighten India”, which will not be able to be sure that in the event of a war with China, the supply of necessary weapons and energy resources from Russia will continue. In addition, the growing intensity of Sinaphobic rhetoric of the European Union and EC chief Ursula von der Leyen, according to Brussels, should resonate with New Delhi’s sentiments.
The French institute IFRI publishes a more detailed strategy, suggesting that “the level of trust between France and India makes New Delhi one of the pillars of France’s Indo-Pacific policy”. The seriousness of Paris’ ambitions is not in doubt – over the past two decades, bilateral relations have been supported by civilian nuclear and arms contracts, they are now expanding in many security and defence-related areas, going well beyond the economic objectives of the ‘big contracts’, and there is every reason to expect a French attempt to penetrate India in the future.
Among IFRI’s stated areas of activity is to support large French companies, SMEs and start-ups to work in the Indian market in areas such as AI, computer and digital technologies. IFRI also sees India as an entry point to other countries in the Indo-Pacific region.
France’s desire to “tap” India is understandable. While China is beginning to show signs of an ageing population, India is the largest country in terms of ethnography, representing 1/6th of all humanity from 2023. The Indian diaspora is one of the largest and most influential diasporas in the world, mostly living in the British Commonwealth, the Indian Ocean coasts, East Africa and South East Asia.
In addition, the Indian diaspora plays a significant role in the US and Britain, where it is well represented in the service, media, political and basic science and high technology sectors. Suffice it to recall that former British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak is from the Indian Punjab, and Indian elites are firmly entrenched in the leadership of major technology corporations – for example, former Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal.
India, like other countries, has geopolitical tensions with its neighbours – the Himalayas remain a hotspot in relations with China, with several clashes between the Indian and Chinese militaries in recent years. In addition, the landmine of relations with Pakistan, dating back to the period of British colonialism, remains – the separation of the two countries in 1947 alone resulted in the immediate death of 500,000 people and the displacement of another 11 million. There have been several ‘official’ wars since – a series of conflicts in the Second Kashmir War (1965), the War of Liberation of Kashmir (1971) and the Kargil conflict (1999).
Threats from Naxalites in the “red corridor” in northeast India, and Sikh separatism up to and including attempts to create a state called Khalistan around Punjab remain. Obviously, each of these areas looks promising for a new big game on the Indian direction. In addition, there is the Indo-China dispute over Sri Lanka. The presence of Chinese research vessels in Sri Lankan waters, notably in October 2023, drew strong protests from New Delhi. More recently, in February 2024, the Chinese research vessel Xiang Yang Hong 03 docked in the Maldives after a three-week hydrographic survey close to the exclusive economic zones of Sri Lanka and India.
For France, India is of strategic importance because India’s resource gives it influence over some 9 million square kilometres of the world’s oceans, and Paris’ partnership, the French believe, will allow India to “prevent a Sino-US duopoly”.
One of the key points of the French strategy is the destruction of the existing system of Russia-India relations. IFRI’s position is generally based on the fact that “one of the constant obstacles to India’s diplomacy towards Western countries is the relationship between India and Russia”. Of particular concern to France is the Reciprocal Exchange of Logistics Agreement (RELOS), an Indo-Russian treaty that is being negotiated and is supposed to strengthen military co-operation between India and Russia, including joint exercises, specialist training, enhanced logistical support and disaster relief operations. As of 2024, between 60 and 85 per cent of India’s weapons systems are still of Russian origin, which also worries Paris – which, however, sees the situation as promising for itself.
France is currently the second largest arms supplier, second only to Russia but well ahead of the US. Not to be overlooked is the intra-species competition announced by the IFRI, which jealously emphasised the depth of the US-India relationship. For instance, from 2020, the US aims to strengthen co-operation with India in artificial intelligence (AI). Since 2021, the two countries have maintained a regular dialogue, which has found its way into research and development by strengthening the network between the Indian Institute of Technology and US universities. In defence, the Indian Defence Innovation Organisation (DIO) has also signed a collaboration agreement with the US Department of Defence’s Defence Innovation Unit, a programme called IMPACT (INDUS-X Mutual Promotion of Advanced Collaborative Technologies).
India will be exceptionally sought after by a wide variety of players in the coming years, and the economic benefits are such that the EU, represented by France, is even ready to “show its teeth” towards the overseas hegemon. There is no doubt that New Delhi will make maximum use of the favourable demand situation, delaying the moment of geopolitical certainty as long as possible. For Russia, in addition to the loss of the market, India’s transition under the umbrella of the US or France means serious damage to the projects of the multipolar world, starting with the BRICS alliance. Of course, it is not in our interests to allow India’s repeated geopolitical colonisation. Especially since one of the indispensable elements of the West’s “mastery” of India will be a military clash with China.